PeaceQuest
  • Home
  • Projects
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Donate
  • Email Us: sstaples@peacequest.ca
  • For teachers: WarandChildren.com
  • Subscribe to our weekly newsletter
PeaceQuest
  • Home
  • Projects
  • Blog
  • About Us
    • Welcome
  • Donate Now

    Scholarship fund studious poor children

    Notice: Test mode is enabled. While in test mode no live donations are processed.

    $
    Select Payment Method
    Personal Info

    Donation Total: $10

Are Putin’s nuclear threats really unprecedented? Or just a logical extension of war?

Homepage Commentary Are Putin’s nuclear threats really unprecedented? Or just a logical extension of war?
Commentary

Are Putin’s nuclear threats really unprecedented? Or just a logical extension of war?

22 April 2022
By Steven Staples
2 Comments
932 Views

There were contrasting views put forward this week by two peace movement thinkers about Russian Federation President Vladimir Putin’s nuclear threats .

In The Nation Magazine on April 20, 2022, Michael T. Klare argues Putin’s order to his military commanders at the outset of the invasion of Ukraine, “to move Russia’s [nuclear] deterrence forces to a special regime of combat duty” is a turning point in modern history.

Klare writes, “Simply by making these threats, Vladimir Putin has transformed the global strategic environment in ways not seen since the height of the Cold War. Until now, it has largely been assumed that nuclear weapons would be used only as a deterrent, to discourage potential adversaries from even considering a nuclear attack for fear of catastrophic retaliation—a condition widely known as ‘mutually assured destruction,’ or MAD.”

“But now, thanks to Putin, nuclear weapons have been repurposed as instruments of war—as cudgels with which to discourage an opponent from engaging in certain offensive behaviors by threatening horrific consequences to the offender. Whatever the outcome of the conflict in Ukraine, this new or repurposed use of nuclear weapons will remain an inescapable feature of any major-power crisis. And, once the threat of nuclear weapons use has been normalized in this way, it is hard to believe they will not be used, sooner or later, to demonstrate the credibility of threats like those issued by Putin,” he writes.

Simply by making these threats, Vladimir Putin has transformed the global strategic environment

MICHAEL T. KLARE

Like Klare, Ray Acheson worries Putin’s nuclear threats and the response by some analysists risk “normalizing” nuclear weapons. Writing on the website of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, she says that the normalization of nuclear weapons is also part of the larger, historical project of normalizing war. 

“In his book The Doomsday Machine, whistleblower and former military analyst Daniel Ellsberg explains that nuclear weapon policies grew out of the justifications for bombing cities and civilians during World War II. The willingness, and even desire, to incinerate civilians and destroy civilian infrastructure as part of the war resulted in the practices of firebombing and blanketing wide areas with explosive violence. This approach characterised the latter part of the war, with major civilian centres being deliberately targeted by allied forces long before the US detonated nuclear bombs over Hiroshima and Nagasaki.”

The potential use of nuclear weapons is an extension of the explosive violence we’re already seeing

RAY ACHESON

“This history provides a disturbing story of how practices previously held abhorrent become normalised during conflict. How what was once held as anathema to ‘civilised behaviour’ becomes entrenched in doctrine and strategy,” says Acheson.

She continues, “The potential use of nuclear weapons is an extension of the explosive violence we’re already seeing in Ukraine, Syria, Yemen, Ethiopia, and elsewhere, and that we already saw in Iraq and Afghanistan, among others. The focus on a potential nuclear war also risks distracting from the lived reality of suffering from ‘conventional war’ going on right now.”

  • Read “Ukraine’s Nuclear Flashpoints: How to avoid Armageddon in the new nuclear era,” by Michael T. Klare, published on April 20, 22 by The Nation
  • Read “Don’t Normalise Nuclear Weapons and War— Abolish Them,” by Ray Acheson, published on April 19 by Reaching Critical Will

For a fascinating look back at the events leading up to the nuclear attacks on Japan by the United States in 1945, watch this episode entitled “Hiroshima” which is part of the series, Greatest Events in World War II in Colour, available on Netflix. Featuring an interview with Setskuo Thurlow.

Tags: Ukraine

Previous Story
Teach-in for Peace on Saturday, April 23
Next Story
Bizarre: Former F-35 test pilot uses conspiracy theories to attack stealth fighter critics

Related Articles

How did 338 Members of Parliament give a standing ovation to a Nazi?

David Pugliese of the Ottawa Citizen breaks it down for...

Silencing pacifists rather than guns in Ukraine

Anti-war organizers are being persecuted

2 replies added

  1. Rose Dyson 23 April 2022

    The explosive growth of violence in society at large has become normalized. Forty years ago people worried about violence creep in popular culture. Subsequent resorts to violence for conflict resolution were discouraged. Today these are non issues. Violence has become a staple ingredient in entertainment. Mass murders in high schools, shopping malls and drive by shootings, frequently precipitated by heavy use of first person shooter video games have been woven into the fabric of our daily lives. The authorities remain focused on gun control and adequacy of police response. The synergy between war mongering and the Hollywood dream machine has been well documented.

  2. Sr. Marilyn Larocque 8 May 2022

    Vladimir Putin’s unhealthy need for power, destructive ways and lack of respect for others has put the whole world on alert. The rest of the world together are striving to find the best discerned way to overcome this major crisis and bring peace to all. It is difficult enough to deal with the covid problems and the healing needs of our planet and all of creation at the same time.

Comments are closed.

Categories

  • Action
  • Analysis
  • Commentary
  • Event
  • PeaceQuest Cape Breton
  • PeaceQuest Kingston
  • PeaceQuest Regina
  • Resource
  • Teachers

Contact

PeaceQuest Leadership and Education Initiative

c/o Steven Staples, Chairperson

225 Sumach Street W303

Toronto  ON M5A 0P8

Email: sstaples@peacequest.ca

Phone: m. 647-327-7187

PeaceQuest Info

  • Projects
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Donate
  • Subscribe

Local Groups

  • Cape Breton
  • Kingston
  • Regina

 

 

Teachers

  • WarandChildren.com
Copyright ©2020 PeaceQuest Leadership and Education Initiative
SearchPostsLogin
Friday, 1, Dec
Don’t use Ukraine as an excuse to abandon nuclear disarmament: Roche
Friday, 1, Dec
Nuclear-armed governments becoming authoritarian, says expert
Thursday, 30, Nov
NATO Climate Killer Part 2: Climate Crossfire Webinar
Friday, 24, Nov
Will the ceasefire hold? Or will war resume
Friday, 24, Nov
IPB head shares challenges working for peace
Friday, 17, Nov
Is Hamas winning?

Welcome back,